Enhancing the QUAlity and Transparency Of health Research

EQUATOR resources in Portuguese | Spanish

Reporting guidelines under development

The following guidelines are currently being developed:

*****

We encourage everyone to submit brief details about their reporting guideline under development for inclusion on the EQUATOR website. This will raise awareness about the development of your guideline and help to prevent duplication. To register your reporting guideline under development please complete our brief registration form (Word document).

*****

Guidelines for reporting the impact of patient and public involvement in research: Strengthening the evidence base of patient and public involvement

REporting Manualised INterventions for Dissemination and Evaluation (REMINDE) Statement

CONSORT Extension for Social and Psychological Interventions: CONSORT-SPI (registered 30 August 2013)

An official extension of the CONSORT 2010 Statement for reporting randomised controlled trials of social and psychological interventions is currently under development. A Delphi process to generate possible reporting standards for the guideline will take place in Fall 2013. Interested stakeholders should contact the project team to get involved in the development and dissemination of the guideline.

STROBE checklist for conference abstracts

The STROBE Group have recently developed a checklist for conference abstracts.

CIRCLe SMT project (Consensus on Interventions Reporting Criteria List Spinal Manipulative Therapy) (registered 2 April 2012)

Guideline for reporting evidence based practice educational interventions and teaching (GREET) statement (registered 4 January 2013)

Developing Standards for Reporting Phase IV Implementation studies (StaRI) (registered 27 September 2013)

Development of a guideline to improve the quality of reporting of Phase IV implementation studies, specifically those with a comparator group.

eMERGe – Meta-ethnography Reporting Guidelines (registered 11 December 2013)

Development of new guidelines for the reporting of meta-ethnography qualitative evidence syntheses.

Preferred Reporting Of CasE SerieS (PROCESS) checklist (registered 3 February 2014)

Case series make up a large portion of the medical literature. This project aims to develop a checklist and guidance document for authors to improve the quality of reporting case series. The literature search is currently ongoing.

Reporting Items for Guidelines in Health Systems (Right) (registered 5 February 2014)

Development of essential reporting items for practice guidelines in health systems to ensure the comprehensive and transparent reporting of such guidelines.

Development of a reporting guideline for pilot and feasibility studies (registered 28 March 2014)

Aim: To develop a reporting guideline for pilot and feasibility studies in preparation for a randomized controlled trial; as an extension to the CONSORT Statement.

Reporting Guidelines for IDEAL Prospective Development and Prospective Exploration Studies (registered 31 March 2014)

The IDEAL (Idea, Development, Exploration, Assessment and Long term follow up) framework (1) allows for the phased and sequential development of a new surgical innovation, optimizing patient safety as the evidence-base builds in a controlled and purposeful manner.

These guidelines aim to improve the completeness of reports and protocols for IDEAL Prospective Development Studies (PDS – phase 2a) and Prospective Exploration Studies (PES – phase 2b).

1. McCulloch P, Altman DG, Campbell WB, et al, for the Balliol Collaboration. No surgical innovation without evaluation: the IDEAL recommendations. Lancet 2009; 374: 1105–12.

Checklist for assessing the reporting of the updating methodology in updated guidelines (registered 15 April 2014)

This project aims to develop a checklist to establish what information and how it should be presented in updated guidelines.

Checklist for the conduct and reporting of micro-costing studies in health care (registered 9 June 2014)

Consort extension to stepped wedge cluster randomised controlled trial (registered 17 July 2014)

To develop an extension to the reporting guideline for parallel cluster trials to produce recommended reporting guidelines for stepped wedge cluster randomised controlled trials.

CONSORT-equity: Improving the relevance of randomized controlled trials for equity-oriented decisions (registered 23 July 2014)

An official extension of the CONSORT 2010 Statement for reporting equity focused randomised controlled trials is currently under development.

Development of a reporting guideline for reporting studies on time to diagnosis (registered 13 August 2014)

Consensus on Exercise Reporting Template (CERT) (registered 17 September 2014)

  • Authors/Steering Committee: Dr Susan Slade, Professor Rachelle Buchbinde, Professor Martin Underwoood, Professor Clermont Dionne.
  • Contact: Dr Susan Slade, susan.slade@monash.edu.au

SPIRIT Extension for trials in Child Health: SPIRIT-C (registered 22 September 2014)

An official extension of the SPIRIT 2013 Statement defining standard protocol items for clinical trials in children is currently under development. A Delphi process to generate possible reporting standards for the guideline has taken place in Q2-3 2014. A Consensus meeting was held 15 September 2014.

CONSORT Extension for trials in Child Health: CONSORT-C (registered 22 September 2014)

An official extension of the CONSORT 2010 Statement for reporting randomised controlled trials in children is currently under development. A Delphi process to generate possible reporting standards for the guideline has taken place in 2009-2010. A systematic review of the literature was conducted Q2-3 2014. A Consensus meeting was held 16 September 2014.

Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analysis – Reporting for Children (PRISMA-C) (registered 6 November 2014)

An official extension of the PRISMA 2009 Statement defining standard reporting items for systematic review in children is currently under development. A Delphi process to generate possible reporting standards for PRISMA-C will take place in Q2/Q3 of 2015. We invite interested stakeholders to participate in the project by contacting the project team.

Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analysis – Protocols for Children (PRISMA-PC) (registered 6 November 2014)

An official extension of the PRISMA-P Statement defining standard protocol items for systematic review in children is currently under development. A Delphi process to generate possible reporting standards for PRISMA-PC will take place in Q2/Q3 of 2015. We invite interested stakeholders to participate in the project by contacting the project team.

GATHER: Guidelines for Accurate and Transparent Health Estimates Reporting (registered 13 March 2015)

GATHER defines best practices for documenting studies that report global health estimates. Global health estimates include all quantitative population-level estimates (including global, regional, national, or subnational estimates) of health indicators, including indicators of health status such as estimates of total and cause-specific mortality, incidence and prevalence of diseases and injuries; and indicators of health determinants, including health behaviours and health exposures.

Adapting TIDieR checklist for reporting public health, health systems and social and environmental policy interventions (UNTIDieR) (registered 26 March 2015)

Adapting TIDieR (Template for Intervention Description and Replication) checklist for reporting public health, health systems and social and environmental policy interventions with potential to affect population health which do not fit well within the existing TIDieR framework.

STARD for Abstracts: Essential items in reporting diagnostic accuracy studies in journal or conference abstracts (registered 29 April 2015)

Diagnostic accuracy studies evaluate the ability of a diagnostic test to correctly identify patients as having or not having a particular disease. Readers of diagnostic accuracy study reports use abstracts to decide whether they should look for the full study report and invest time in reading it. This decision requires an informative description of the purpose, methods and results of the study. However, abstracts of diagnostic accuracy studies often insufficiently report such information, making it difficult for readers to appraise the potential for bias and the applicability of the study findings.
Our goal is to develop, disseminate and implement a robust reporting guideline that will help improve the informativeness of abstracts of diagnostic accuracy studies regarding essential items that are needed to evaluate elements of study validity.

Reporting of orthotic (splinting) interventions (registered 6 July 2015)

This guideline is intended as an extension or add-on to other guidelines for specific research designs. It addresses how orthotic interventions should be reported within the context of any given quantitative study design.

Reporting guidelines for implementation research and operational research (registered 12 August 2015)

Implementation research involves increasing access to health products and strategies that are already available and have been shown to work but remain beyond the reach of many of the people who could benefit from them. It is rooted in the identification of practical problems facing disease control programmes and in finding solutions which improve access to health interventions and lead to better health outcomes. Different research methods may be used depending on the type of problem studied.

Operational research uses an existing resource – the data routinely collected by programmes – to provide ways of improving programme operations and thereby delivering more effective, efficient and equitable care. Implementation and operational research are usually carried out in close collaboration between researchers and disease control programme staff.

Reporting of Home Visiting Effectiveness/Efficacy Research (RoHVER) (registered 2 September 2015)

This project aims to develop a comprehensive set of reporting guidelines for home visiting that improve and enhance the accuracy of reporting home visiting intervention evaluations. Specifically, the reporting guidelines focus on: (1) reporting effectiveness and efficacy studies, (2) incorporation of study designs endorsed by the Home Visiting Effectiveness of Evidence (HomVEE), and (3) inclusion of more thorough guidelines for reporting home visiting intervention design and implementation data.

COS-STAR: a reporting guideline for studies developing core outcome sets (registered 4 September 2015)

PRISMA-RR 2017: an extension to PRISMA for rapid reviews (registered 4 November 2015)

This reporting guideline will address reporting for rapid reviews, including those with analogous terminology (e.g., rapid evidence synthesis, rapid knowledge synthesis).

  • Protocol is forthcoming. The reporting guideline will be based on the EQUATOR guidance for developing reporting guidelines (PLoS Med 2010;7(2):e1000217).
  • Contact: Adrienne Stevens, adstevens@ohri.ca

PRISMA-DTA: Checklist for reporting of diagnostic test accuracy systematic reviews (registered 18 November 2015)

The objective is to develop and implement a guideline for reporting diagnostic test accuracy systematic reviews and meta-analyses – Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analysis of Diagnostic Test Accuracy (PRISMA-DTA).

Instrument for the Selection of Primary Endpoints in Clinical Trials (InSPECT) – An evidence and consensus based reporting tool (registered 18 November 2015)

A new evidence and consensus based reporting checklist for primary outcomes in clinical trial protocols and reports is currently under development. Clinical trialists, evidence end-users including systematic reviewers, and those involved in reporting guidelines development would be major beneficiaries of this checklist. It is the next step forward in current efforts to produce and harmonize transparent and reproducible RCT protocols and reports.

SPIRIT Extension for N-of-1 Trial Protocols (SPENT) (registered 18 November 2015)

SPENT will extend the SPIRIT Statement (Standardized Protocol Items: Recommendations for Interventional Trials) to the reporting of individual and series N-of-1 trial protocols.

Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis extension for Scoping Reviews (PRISMA-ScR) (registered 18 December 2015)

The objective is to develop a guideline to standardize the reporting of scoping reviews – Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis extension for Scoping Reviews (PRISMA-ScR).

PRISMA-CI: Reporting Guidelines for Systematic Reviews of Complex Interventions (registered 7 January 2016)

The Complex Interventions Workgroup aimed to develop PRISMA-CI as a stand-alone extension to the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) Statement. Development of PRISMA-IPD followed the EQUATOR Network framework guidance and used the existing standard PRISMA Statement as a starting point to draft additional relevant material. The statement development process included a literature review; interviews; and a modified Delphi process of international experts including researchers, clinicians, health system delivery representatives, methodologists, journal editors, reviewers, and funders; in-person conference discussions; iterative refinements of workgroups and an advisory group, and the Complex Interventions Workgroup reached agreement on the PRISMA-CI checklist by consensus.

  • Additional information: This PRISMA-CI is part of a special series on Complex Interventions for the Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, the last of seven papers.
  • Contact: Makalapua L. Motu’apuaka, Makalapua.motu’apuaka@va.gov

PRISMA-Search: guidelines for reporting systematic review literature searches (registered 17 February 2016)

Checklist for One Health Epidemiological Reporting of Evidence (COHERE) (registered 29 February 2016)

The goals of COHERE are 1) to improve the quality of reporting of observational epidemiology studies integrating data on humans, animals and/or vectors, and their shared environments, and 2) to promote the concept that one health studies should integrate data from these three sectors.

Surgical Case Reports – SCARE (registered 22 April 2016)

A reporting guideline for surgical case reports.

Patent Landscape Reporting Guidelines (registered 9 June 2016)

We recently conducted a systematic review investigating reporting quality of patent or landscapes in the life sciences that is currently in preparation for submission. The systematic review concluded that articles pertaining to the reporting of patent landscaping were of overall poor quality. Notably, we found a lack of reporting of essential methodological elements with very few manuscripts providing enough information for them to be reproducible. This presents a significant problem as intellectual property (IP) plays a key role within life science research and the information provided in these reviews could very well be used to inform the decisions of academic centres, companies funding and policy. We therefore propose the development of guidelines for the reporting of patent/IP guidelines.

EMERGE (ESPACOMP Medication Adherence reporting Guidelines) (registered 22 June 2016)

An initiative taken by a working group of ESPACOMP (the European Society for Patient Adherence, COMpliance, and Persistence) to develop guidelines for reporting research on medication adherence building on the ABC taxonomy for medication adherence (Vrijens et al. British Journal of Clinical Pharmacology 2012 PMID: 22486599).

Reporting guideline for randomised controlled trials to discontinue chronic medication (registered 26 July 2016)

The guideline aims to provide items to use in the reporting of randomised controlled trials in which chronic medication is discontinued. The guideline can be used as an addition to the CONSORT statement.

 

When guideline development is completed and the guideline is published we will remove it from this list and include it in our database of reporting guidelines.

Please do let us know about relevant projects; it will avoid duplication of the process and might also help you to find new collaborators. To register your reporting guideline under development please complete our brief registration form (Word document).

 

Page last updated on: 26 July 2016

 

Translations

Some reporting guidelines are also available in languages other than English. Find out more in our Translations section.

About the Library

For information about Library scope and content, identification of reporting guidelines and inclusion/exclusion criteria please visit About the Library.

Visit our Help page for information about searching for reporting guidelines and for general information about using our website.

Our full catalogue of reporting guidelines is available to download as a PDF: Reporting Guideline Catalogue May 2014.